Prime Rib or Turkey

[AlaskaGuy]

I've been cooking the turkey w/oyster stuffing (dressing is for communist) for the past eight years now ... family get together and I'm getting the sh1ts of it. That and I'm not all that big on turkey to begin with so I thought a prime rib roast would be a nice change. Thoughts?

or ...

 

[batchaps4me]

(dressing is for communist)

For the first time, across at least three MBs and several years, I will say that you have made a post worthy of a ban hammer. There is nothing better than a pan of chicken dressing.

 

[tinp]

Potato Salad for the win...

 

[Bama Believer]

I liked the post because the concept is good, I love some prime rib, why not on the Thanksgiving day,, but you lose serious credit for your opinion on dressing, Yankee stuffing is made with white bread crumbled up in some turkey stock with some sage thrown in, cornbread dressing is made with cornbread obviously but eggs are also drizzled in before baking, you obviously have never had a good plate of dressing with giblet gravy!

 

[Hard2Bluff]

In OP's defense, I love me some oyster casserole. Gotta have the the broccoli casserole also. However, ya gotta have some stuffing n gravy on the side.

 

[AlaskaGuy]

I liked the post because the concept is good, I love some prime rib, why not on the Thanksgiving day,, but you lose serious credit for your opinion on dressing, Yankee stuffing is made with white bread crumbled up in some turkey stock with some sage thrown in, cornbread dressing is made with cornbread obviously but eggs are also drizzled in before baking, you obviously have never had a good plate of dressing with giblet gravy!

I use two bags of seasoned bread crumbs, chopped onion, chopped celery, egg, chopped up turkey innards, and two jars of oysters (chopped up).

 

[Bama Believer]

Sound good

 

[Basement Bias]

I love turkey so you know how I voted.

 

[Wunder.Noid]

it's hard to beat Prime Rib any day of the week.

 

[TechRaiderRider]

 

[BlkSabbath74]

I've been cooking the turkey w/oyster stuffing (dressing is for communist) for the past eight years now ... family get together and I'm getting the sh1ts of it. That and I'm not all that big on turkey to begin with so I thought a prime rib roast would be a nice change. Thoughts?

or ...

Given the choice between beef and bird, I’m always going with beef.

 

[RazzlDazzl]

So limited in choices. Thanksgiving and Christmas Eve we start early with fresh Apalachicola oysters, then fried shrimp and scallops, then a cold smoked/fried turkey, smoked pork shoulder, glazed ham, all the fixings, and plenty of booze.

Expand your horizons.

 

[RuffledFeathers]

A proper fried turkey is best, but would likely prefer prime rib over a pedestrian baked turkey.

I recently read that you shouldn't eat turkey because it is a close cousin to a a buzzard.

 

[OldDevilDawg]

A proper fried turkey is best, but would likely prefer prime rib over a pedestrian baked turkey.

I recently read that you shouldn't eat turkey because it is a close cousin to a a buzzard.

Chicken is still delicious, though, so you got that going for you.

 

[BlkSabbath74]

So limited in choices. Thanksgiving and Christmas Eve we start early with fresh Apalachicola oysters, then fried shrimp and scallops, then a cold smoked/fried turkey, smoked pork shoulder, glazed ham, all the fixings, and plenty of booze.

Expand your horizons.

Appalachian Oysters…is that any thing like Rocky Mountain Oysters?

 

[Nod4Eight]

View attachment 7391

This was my first reaction. It's not a zero-sum game.

 

[Wunder.Noid]

This was my first reaction. It's not a zero-sum game.

Where the fvck you been cowboy?